Industrial systems, once of little interest to hackers, are now targeted on a regular basis, making security an ever-growing concern. At the same time, as more companies update and add to their control systems, the OPC industrial protocol continues to grow in popularity. So it would make sense to ask the question, how vulnerable to attack is an industrial system that uses OPC?
A recent white paper by Claroty, Exploring the OPC Attack Surface, discusses a number of security vulnerabilities in the products of three well-known suppliers of OPC software. These issues, reported to the Industrial Control System Cyber Emergency Response Team (ICS-CERT), could “expose organizations to remote code execution, denial-of-service conditions on ICS devices, and information leaks,” according to the report.
The companies involved have isolated the bugs, fixed them, and issued upgrades to their software, but the underlying problem remains. All software has bugs, and OPC software is no exception. Every connection to the Internet risks exposing an attack surface that could be exploited.
Like most industrial protocols, OPC was conceived and developed before the advent of Industrie 4.0 and the Industrial IoT. Back then, nobody seriously considered connecting their process control systems to the Internet. All production equipment and networks were entirely disconnected (“air-gapped”) from the outside world, or at least secured behind closed firewalls.
Connecting a factory or industrial process to an IT department or cloud service introduces risk. The design of OPC requires an open firewall port to make a connection. Most companies are currently using workarounds to overcome this Achilles heel, but none of them are adequate. Using a VPN simply expands the security perimeter of a control network to the outside world of phishing emails and ransomware attacks. Using an IoT gateway to connect an OPC server to a cloud service still requires connecting the plant network to the Internet in some way.
The most secure approach
Instead, the most secure way to get data from OPC servers running on a plant network is by using one or more DMZs. According to a recent NIST report, “The most secure, manageable, and scalable control network and corporate network segregation architectures are typically based on a system with at least three zones, incorporating one or more DMZs.”
Using a DMZ makes it possible to isolate the plant from the Internet. Although OPC alone cannot connect through multiple hops across a DMZ, adding Skkynet’s DataHub technology makes it possible. A DataHub tunnel for OPC can establish secure, real-time data flow across the connection, without opening any inbound firewall ports. This effectively cuts the attack surface to zero. Even if there is an undiscovered bug lurking somewhere in an OPC server, there is much less risk. After all, hackers cannot attack what they can’t see.